15 Years of Progress and Change in Court-Ordered Testing
Over the past 15 years, drug, alcohol, and DNA testing has transformed dramatically in the context of family law. With courts increasingly relying on scientific evidence to inform decisions in custody, care proceedings, and safeguarding cases, the demand for reliable, non-invasive, and legally defensible testing methods has never been higher.
Today’s testing landscape offers a wide range of tools that go far beyond basic screening, helping courts paint a fuller picture of patterns of behaviour, substance misuse, and familial relationships. In this blog, we explore how far we've come — and why it matters.
From Simple Screens to Complex Case Evidence
Fifteen years ago, drug and alcohol testing was far more limited in scope. Urine tests were widely used due to cost and accessibility, but they could only identify recent use, typically within 1–3 days. This presented challenges in family law, where the court often needs insight into long-term patterns of behaviour.
Today, the field includes:
- Hair strand testing: Offering a segmented, month-by-month view of drug or alcohol use over a 3–6 month period.
- Nail testing: Providing a longer detection window and an alternative to hair, especially useful for people with little or no head hair.
- Oral fluid testing: Ideal for detecting very recent use, often used in emergency situations or supervised settings.
- Blood testing: Including PEth testing for alcohol — a direct biomarker of consumption over the previous 2–4 weeks.
- DNA testing: From paternity to sibling and grandparent tests, advances in relationship testing are now faster, more accurate, and admissible in court.
These developments provide deeper insights and support more balanced, evidence-led judgments in family court.
Advances in Collection Methods
Not only have testing technologies evolved — the collection processes have too. Sample collection is now more secure, less invasive, and chain-of-custody protocols have become stricter to ensure admissibility in legal proceedings.
For example, for hair strand drug or alcohol tests, we can now perform more analysis on less hair. This saves on the costs of running a machine multiple times and also makes life better for the donor for cosmetic reasons.
Understanding the Limitations: A More Informed Approach
While testing has advanced, so has our understanding of its limitations. For example:
- Hair treatments such as bleaching or dyeing can alter hair structure and affect drug concentration.
- Blood tests for alcohol (like PEth) are highly accurate but only reflect recent use.
- Nail testing offers long windows of detection but doesn't provide segmented analysis.
This nuanced understanding allows courts and legal professionals to choose the right test — or combination of tests — based on the unique context of each case.
DNA Testing: The Rise of Relationship Clarity
Fifteen years ago, DNA testing was a lengthy, expensive process. Today, it’s widely accessible, with faster turnaround times and robust accuracy. Courts now rely on DNA results to resolve complex disputes — from verifying paternity to clarifying sibling or grandparent relationships.
These tests are particularly valuable when determining care arrangements, financial responsibilities, or child placement in social care cases.
Combining Tests for Clearer Outcomes
Modern family law cases increasingly benefit from a multi-test approach. For example:
- A hair drug test might reveal historic use.
- A blood alcohol test (PEth) might confirm recent alcohol consumption.
- A nail test could offer additional evidence in cases where hair is unsuitable.
This layered methodology provides courts with a broader, more balanced view of substance misuse patterns, strengthening the reliability of findings and supporting child welfare outcomes.
A Final Word: Testing That Holds Up in Court
Today, it’s not just about detecting substances - it’s about presenting evidence that stands up in court. That means full chain-of-custody records, laboratory accreditation, expert witness statements, and the use of accredited testing providers.
The evolution of drug, alcohol, and DNA testing has brought us to a point where science and law can work hand-in-hand to protect families and children - and that progress should be celebrated.
Watch Webinar